When a new online show, run by a person in a bunny costume, "Which Would You Prefer" threatens Would You Wrather, Coop, Cami, and Fred set out to find who is behind the mask. Meanwhile, Charlotte gets Jenna on social media.
Paula is unemployed and uncertain of her future. Her best friend Jeff is heart broken and unable to move on from his most recent relationship. Together they embark on a road trip from Los Angeles to Paula's hometown of Seattle looking for answers.